Introduction
Over the last 25 years technology has flourished in education, going from a single display, keyboard, and mouse to the unlimited possibilities that now come with the digital world (Dillenbourg, 2016). Today, the 2022 Curriculum for Wales Digital Competence Framework outlines that students will become “digital citizens who contributes positively to the digital world around them and who critically evaluates their place within the digital world” (Welsh Government, 2022). In this blog post, we will explore how this new, unlimited technology can be used effectively in the classroom by firstly looking at the SAMR module, and how teachers can use this to aid them in their planning and delivery of the digital resources available. Secondly, we will be looking at what impact experience has on the teaching of technology and finally, we will look at examples of how teachers can use technology effectively in their classroom.
The SAMR Module
Developed in 2006 by Dr. Ruben R. Puentdura, the SAMR module looks at how educators can enhance their use of technology in their classroom settings (Romrell et al., 2014). This module is set out like the picture shown and consists of four classifications: Substitution, Augmentation, Modification and Redefinition.
The module was designed this way to encourage teachers to move from the bottom layer of substitution, to eventually reaching the highest level and redefining their own tasks using a form of technology; this in turn can lead to greater levels of learning (Hamilton, Rosenberg and Akcaoglu, 2016). Technology is increasingly entering the classroom across primary settings – the SAMR module provides an approach for teachers when considering how to integrate this technology into their teaching to transform the student’s learning (Hilton, 2016). Here is a video that explains more about the SAMR module:
In a seminar, we effectively used a green screen to create images of ourselves and others in different scenarios. Here is me in New York City. With these images, we were able to post them onto Twitter and have other students, staff, and schools’ comment back and collaborate with us. This task was fun, engaging, and simple for all ages to participate in. It redefined the lesson, allowing us to teleport to anywhere in the world, previously inconceivable before this technology was brought in. Blacer-Bacolod (2022) argues that using green screen technology supports learning by developing digital skills, increasing motivation, increased engagement, and all-round active learning. Taking this, the SAMR module and our participation into consideration, it could be argued that green screen is an efficient way for teachers to use technology in the classroom.
Experienced Users
In today’s society, the education system contains both digital natives and immigrants (Jude, et al., 2014). Digital Native students are people born after 1980, growing up in the digital age and around technology, whereas Digital Immigrants commonly are learning how to use technology as adults (Prensky, 2001). He also argues that digital immigrants make themselves known in several ways, an example being printing out a document and filling it out with paper and pen rather than editing the document online and emailing it back (Prensky, 2001).
Here are some of the typical stereotypes that come with the Digital Immigrant or Digital Native titles:
Gaston (2006) argues that one of the biggest issues in today’s education is that students have grown up in this interactive and highly stimulating environment (digital natives) and are struggling to be taught and reached by the teachers who did not (digital immigrants). However, Guo (2008) argues that there is “limited information regarding the relationship between age and ICT competency”. Looking at this, it could suggest that so long as adequate training is given to teachers of all abilities, they will excel in the digital world. Speaking from a personal perspective, being a Digital Native, I have been expected to know how to use a new piece of technology, although never having seen or worked with it before. I did pick it up quite quickly, whereas someone who is a Digital Immigrant may have struggled.
Luan et al. (2005) conducted a studied which concluded that teachers who had longer exposure to technology and were therefore more experienced, had more control over the internet and how they used it in education. It’s like the old saying – practice make perfect. The more practice and experience teachers and students have with technology, then the more digital competent they are going to feel.
How can teachers use technology effectively?
So, taking everything into consideration, how can teachers use technology effectively in a classroom setting? In our seminars, we had experience with a multitude of different pieces of technology, including the green screen mentioned previously and this short stop motion animation that was created by myself and my team using a stop motion video maker app on the iPads
Creating this stop motion animation allowed us to play around with technology that we had never experienced before. By the end of the seminar, we were able to set up the iPads on a tripod and complete this task with little to no help given. Wishart (2017) argues that using stop motion animation in a classroom setting not only promotes digital learning but creates opportunities for discussion and collaboration between peers. It was also found that it allowed them to experience storyboarding, editing and even art when physically creating their characters (Wishart, 2017).
Another way that teachers can effectively use technology is through the world of Virtual Reality (VR). I recently visited Maerdy Community Primary School and was lucky enough to help set up and conduct lesson using the VR headset with a reception class. In this lesson, the students were able to fully immerse themselves into the land of the minibeasts. With the ClassVR headsets, we were able to scaffold their learning and engage them in exploring the topic at hand.
Using VR in the classroom allows students to have first-person experience that were previously inconceivable and allows them to process their learning and reflection of the task differently to what they may have done before (Martín-Gutiérrez et al., 2017). This suggests that VR is an effective use for technology in the classroom.
Reference List:
Blacer-Bacolod, D. (2022) ‘Student-Generated Videos Using Green Screen Technology in a Biology Class’, International Journal of Information and Education Technology, 12(4), pp. 339-345
Dillenbourg, P. (2016) ‘The Evolution of Research on Digital Education’, International Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education, 26(2), pp. 544–560
Gaston, J. (2006) ‘Reaching and Teaching Digital Natives’, Library Hi Tech News, 23(3), pp. 12–13
Guo, R.X., Dobson, T. and Petrina, S. (2008) ‘Digital Natives, Digital Immigrants: An Analysis of Age and Ict Competency in Teacher Education’, Journal of Educational Computing Research, 38(3), pp. 235–254.
Hamilton, E.R., Rosenberg, J.M. and Akcaoglu, M. (2016) ‘The Substitution Augmentation Modification Redefinition (SAMR) Model: A Critical Review and Suggestions for its Use’, TechTrends, 60(5), pp. 433–441
Hilton, J.T. (2016) ‘A Case Study of the Application of SAMR and TPACK for Reflection on Technology Integration into Two Social Studies Classrooms’, Social studies (Philadelphia, Pa : 1934), 107(2), pp. 68–73
Jude, L.T., Kajura, M.A. & Birevu, M.P. (2014) ‘Adoption of the SAMR Model to Asses ICT Pedagogical Adoption: A Case of Makerere University’, International Journal of e-Education, e-Business, e-Management and e-Learning, 4(2), pp. 106-115
Luan, W.S., Fung, N.S., Nawawi, M., & Hong, T.S. (2005) ‘Experienced and inexperienced Internet users among pre-service teachers: Their use and attitudes toward the Internet’, Educational Technology & Society, 8(1), pp. 90–103
Martín-Gutiérrez, J., Mora, C.E., Añorbe-Díaz, B. & González-Marrero, A. (2017) ‘Virtual Technologies Trends in Education’, Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 13(2), pp. 469-486
Prensky, M. (2001) ‘Digital Natives, Digital Immigrants Part 2: Do They Really Think Differently?’, On The Horizon, 9(6), pp. 1–6
Romrell, D., Kidder, L.C. and Wood, E. (2014) ‘The SAMR Model as a framework for evaluating mLearning’, Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 18(2), p. 1-15
Welsh Government (2022) Digital Competence Framework. Available at: https://hwb.gov.wales/curriculum-for-wales/cross-curricular-skills-frameworks/digital-competence-framework [Accessed on: 20/04/22]
Wishart, J. (2017) ‘Exploring How Creating Stop-Motion Animations Supports Student Teachers in Learning to Teach Science’, Journal of Research on Technology in Education, 49(1-2), pp. 88–101
Introduction
Across education, one of the most harmful ideas is that having a ‘math brain’ is possible, as it allows students to believe that high achievement is only accessible to some (Boaler et al., 2018). This can cause what is known as Maths anxiety. Maths anxiety is a common issue in education as having this fear towards the subject directly links to a student’s performance (Maloney et al., 2015). Maths anxiety can form from many places, Whyte and Anthony (2012) argue that it can stem directly from parents who unintentionally transfer their stress and fear of numeracy from their school days on to their child. Here is a video which explains Math anxiety in more detail, and how it can harm students in their academic success:
In this blog we will be looking at just some of the ways in which improving mindsets and tackling anxiety can be achieved. We will be looking at what academic sources say regarding the benefits and barriers of improving students’ attitude towards Maths including the ‘growth mindset’ mentioned in the video above.
So what can be done?
The teaching of textbook Maths is widespread (Schoenfeld, 1985) and can be argued that current textbooks are, on occasion, irrelevant to real world mathematical problems (Le Roux, 2008). It is argued that teaching Maths in this regimental style can be ‘boring’ and ‘difficult’ for the students to participate in (Kislenko et al., 2007) and therefore, contributes towards a negative attitude towards Maths as a whole. I asked my friends and family what their thoughts and feelings were on Maths and what it was like for them at school, here is the results:
Their attitudes towards Maths and numeracy were very mixed. Personally, I enjoyed Maths throughout my whole time at school and looked forward to completing lessons and work related to the subject. I believe I enjoyed Maths as I loved to be challenged so every question I had correct felt like a little victory. During my placement and whilst working in different schools, the blanket opinion was that Maths is not liked, aside from a few instances where teachers had made Maths ‘fun’. In the Successful Futures Report, Donaldson (2015) states that:
“Children and young people need regular opportunities to deepen their understanding of number and, as with literacy, to reinforce and use their numeracy skills in different contexts.”
This indicates that numeracy should be taught as a cross-curriculum subject to enable students in Wales to use number in different contexts’ every day. The 2022 Curriculum for Wales agrees with this and highlights the importance of Maths and numeracy by stating, “The development of mathematics has always gone hand in hand with the development of civilisation itself.” (Welsh Government, 2022).
One of the ways in which maths can be taught cross-curricular is through the outdoors. Sargent (2015) suggests that the outdoor environment can offer unique opportunities for Maths that were inconceivable in the classroom setting. Whilst working at Blaengwawr Primary in Aberdare, we took Maths outdoors by asking the students to find as many bugs as they could and record what they found.
Being in a natural place of learning with all different resources allowed students to have different opportunities for activities such as collecting information, sorting, problem solving and exploration (Keith, 2017). Once the children had collected enough information, we continued the lesson by creating graphs from what the students had found. This was a fun and exciting way for the children to engage with the task at hand.
Another way to improve student’s attitudes towards Maths is to have them physically engage with the task. Riley et al. (2017) suggests that movement-based activities in a Maths lesson allow for peer-assisted learning and class discussions to be promoted. Recently in our seminar we did just this with a place-value activity. We all had a card with a place-value and had to work together to arrange ourselves in the correct order. We then went onto create an animal themed place-value activity with the help of Michael the Mathematical Monkey.
Another highly encouraged way to change the attitudes towards Maths in a classroom is to promote a growth mindset to the students. Dweck (2012) explains that a growth mindset is,
“The belief that intelligence can be developed, for example, through personal effort, good learning strategies, and lots of mentoring and support from others”.
One of these learning strategies is the power of making mistakes. When people make mistakes, it helps the brain to grow (growth mindset) – it helps us understand critical information needed, as students often tend to put themselves down when they make a mistake in Math (Boaler and Dweck, 2015). Making mistakes is seen to build the growth mindset and produce self-generated adjustments in education (Moser et al., 2011). It could be argued that promoting this growth mindset in primary school classrooms could improve the attitudes of Welsh students as they are encouraged to make mistake and have a trail and error approach to their learning.
Conclusion
In this blog we have looked at just some of the strategies that can be implemented to improve the attitudes to Maths in Welsh primary classrooms. Firstly, this blog explored why Maths as a whole has a negative reputation and found that some people suffer what is known as Math anxiety. Having Maths anxiety can negatively impact the way in which students’ approach and deal with the subject. Then this blog sort out some examples of what can be done to improve these attitudes, including outdoor learning, movement in maths and encouraging a growth mindset in the classroom. All of these examples were seen to have a positive effect on the way in which students perceived maths and should ideally be implemented within Welsh primary classrooms.
Reference List:
Boaler, J., Dieckmann, J.A., Pérez-Núñez, G., Sun, K.L. and Williams, C. (2018) ‘Changing Students Minds and Achievement in Mathematics: The Impact of a Free Online Student Course’, Frontiers in Education, 3(26), pp. 1-7
Boaler, J. & Dweck, C.S. (2015) Mathematical Mindsets: Unleashing Students' Potential Through Creative Math, Inspiring Messages and Innovative Teaching. San Francisco: John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated
Dweck, C.S. (2012) Mindset. London: Robinson
Donaldson, G. (2015) Successful Futures: Independent Review of Curriculum and Assessment Arrangements in Wales. Available at: https://gov.wales/sites/default/files/publications/2018-03/successful-futures.pdf [Accessed on: 29/04/22]
Keith, L. (2018) Developing Young Children’s Mathematical Learning Outdoors: Linking Pedagogy and Practice. 1st ed. Milton: Routledge
Kislenko, K., Grevholm, B. and Lepik, M. (2007) ‘Mathematics is important but boring: students’ beliefs and attitudes towards mathematics’, Relating Practice and Research in Mathematics Education, pp. 1-12
Le Roux, K. (2008) ‘A Critical Discourse Analysis of a Real-World Problem in Mathematics: Looking for Signs of Change’, Language and Education, 22(5), pp. 307-326
Maloney, E.A., Ramirez, G., Gunderson, E.A., Levine, S.C. & Bilock, S.L. (2015) ‘Intergenerational Effects of Parents’ Math Anxiety on Children’s Math Achievement and Anxiety’, Psychological Science, 26(9), pp. 1480-1488
Moser, J.S., Schroder, H.S., Heeter, C., Moran, T.P. & Lee, Y. (2011) ‘Mind Your Errors: Evidence for a Neural Mechanism Linking Growth Mind-Set to Adaptive Posterror Adjustments’, Psychological Science, 22(12), pp. 1484–1489
Riley, N. et al. (2017) ‘Movement-based Mathematics: Enjoyment and Engagement without Compromising Learning through the EASY Minds Program’, Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 13(6).
Sargent, M. (2015) Developing Early Maths Skills Outdoors: Activity Ideas and Best Practice for Teaching and Learning Outside. London: Practical Pre-School Books
Schoenfeld, A.H. (1985) Mathematical Problem Solving. Orlando, Florida: Academic Press
Welsh Government (2022) Area of Learning and Experience: Mathematics and Numeracy. Available at: https://hwb.gov.wales/curriculum-for-wales/mathematics-and-numeracy/ [Accessed on: 29/04/22]
Whyte, J. & Anthony, G. (2012) ‘Maths anxiety: the fear factor in the mathematics classroom’, New Zealand Journal of Teachers’ Work, 9(1), pp. 6–15
Description of the Experience
For my placement, I chose to attend Ysgol Nantgywn in Tonypandy. This setting is a 3 to 16 ‘All-through School’ that has many students of all abilities including an Additional Learning Needs (ALN) department. There is also a Flying Start Nursery on site, which gave me the opportunity to gain a small insight of what it would be like to work with those aged 18 months to 3 years old.
Throughout my 24 hours, I assisted in many classes, including the nursery, Year 5 Maya lesson, Year 8 Science, Year 11 Sports Lesson, and an ALN Speech and Language session. During these different sessions, I was able to aid the teacher in any way they needed, including preparing the activities, helping to design a Maya mask and even being in goals for the girl’s football team (I was not very good).
This placement was to explore the alternative types of settings to Primary Education to be able to make an informed decision on my career in the future. I chose to attend Ysgol Nantgywn as it had many of these alternative options all in one place. Having completed this placement, I believe that becoming a Primary Education teacher is still my long-term goal.
Feelings and Thoughts about the Experience
Being an alumnus of the school, it was a great experience to re-visit the halls and classrooms that I was once in as a student myself. I felt nervous prior to attending, however when I was placed into a classroom I felt at ease. All the teachers and staff members I worked with throughout the 24-hour period made me feel welcome and helped me as much as they could.
When working with the Year 11 class, my thoughts and feelings were extremely different to working with the nursery or the ALN students. Being with the Year 11 students, I felt very intimidated and quite overwhelmed, trying my upmost to gain their approval and mutual respect. In the nursery, my thoughts were more along the lines of, “it’s my job to keep these children alive”, which added pressure and stress, but all went smoothly once I was there.
Evaluation of the Experience, both good and bad
Overall, I would say my experience was great. One of the activities that went well was the Year 8 science lessons. This was a double lesson where we were able to experiment with different metals and how they react to a flame. The students were engaged in the activity and the moral in the classroom was high. When I was in school, I also enjoyed Science so I think that contributed to my experience with this class.
One of the experiences that did not go so well was working with the ALN children. One of the students who I was trying to read with decided to throw the book at me and climb up the wall onto a high windowsill. Luckily, I was not on my own in this situation and one of the support staff assisted me in encouraging him to come back down to the ground. On a separate occasion, I was hit in the side of the head and screamed at by a non-verbal autistic boy for not allowing him to force feed another child. This setting has allowed me to conclude that a career in the ALN sector is not for myself. It was very challenging, and I do not think I have the mental ability to be in that situation every day.
Analysis to Make Sense of the Situation
Throughout my own time in Ysgol Nantgwyn, I enjoyed most of my lessons and have very good memories from being at that school. I believe that my attitude toward this school contributed to the success I felt in this placement. I also believe that my professionalism, positivity, and drive to do my very best helped my placement go as well as it did. Schweingruber (2006) states that having a positive mental attitude can contribute to success. This video show how a positive mental attitude can physically affect you:
Alternatively, the hours that did not go well (as stated above) were down to a pure lack of training. Many pieces of literature, including a study by Sahinidis and Bouris (2007) argues that there is a direct correlation between training and employee success. As this was only an observational placement, there was no training required. However, I believe if I had some training, more time and understanding with the ALN students, my experience with them would not have gone as bad as it did.
Conclusion
From completing this placement at an alternative setting, I have learnt that my overall goal is still to become a Primary School Teacher. Working with students outside the ages of 3 to 11 is not for me, even though I did enjoy my short period with them. However, I did thoroughly enjoy working with the Flying Start nursery as well. I believe that some of the skills I need to develop is communication with others of all ages and abilities, I think if I had had more time with the same students, everything would have been more successful. Looking back, I could have taken the time before my placement to research how to control situations with ALN students, that way I would have been more prepared for the situations that occurred.
Action Plan
This step I created on the digital platform Canva to allow myself to clearly view what needed to be completed
Reference List:
Sahinidis, A.G. and Bouris, J. (2008) ‘Employee perceived training effectiveness relationship to employee attitudes’, Journal of European Industrial Training, 32(1), pp. 63–76
Schweingruber, D. (2006) ‘Success Through A Positive Mental Attitude?: The Role of Positive Thinking in Door-to-Door Sales’, Sociological Quarterly, 47(1), pp. 41-68
Placement Timesheet
THANK YOU
Credits:
Created with images by tonefotografia - "A little cute girl is using laptop for studying online via internet at home. E-learning Concept during quarantine time." • Johnstocker - "Blackboard inscribed with scientific formulas and calculations in physics, mathematics and electrical circuits. Science and education background."