Loading

IRLE Year at a Glance 2020/2021 ANNUAL REPORT

In these unprecedented times, the Institute for Research on Labor and Employment remains a vital and dynamic center of research activity and policy engagement. The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted every aspect of the economy, upending the lives and livelihoods of workers across the country, deepening existing inequities, and intensifying already urgent policy debates about inequality, equity, and the future of work.

IRLE has long been at the forefront of these conversations, and our research teams have been uniquely poised to respond to the moment with timely data-driven insights and policy recommendations to rebuild a stronger and more just foundation for workers moving forward.

Learn more about our work over the past year to fulfill our critical mission of connecting world-class research with policy to improve workers’ lives, communities, and society.

Student Programs

Despite the campus closure last year, IRLE continued to provide funding, mentorship, community, and research opportunities to emerging labor scholars. By creating opportunities for more students, we aim to contribute to the diversity of the next generation of labor and employment scholars, activists, and practitioners.

Through our IRLE-supported faculty research groups, 32 undergraduates had the opportunity to participate in faculty research groups across campus, including:

  • Underground Scholars Research & Policy Team, led by David Harding and Christopher Muller (Sociology)
  • The Latinx and the Environment Initiative (LEI), led by Federico Castillo (Environmental Science, Policy, and Management) and Lupe Gallegos (Chicanx Latinx Academic Student Development Center)
  • Positive Outcomes in Post-Foster Care Young Adulthood: The Welfare State in US and Norway, led by Jill Duerr Berrick (Social Welfare)
  • Undocumented Research Cohort, led by Irene Bloemraad and Cybelle Fox (Sociology)

Students worked with faculty PIs to produce briefs and reports across a range of social sciences topics. Our new student brief series offers student researchers a chance to publish and disseminate their original research.

Social Sciences Research Pathways

Last year, we piloted the Social Sciences Research Pathways (SSRP) program, matching 18 undergraduate mentees with six graduate student-led research projects. Through the program, undergraduate mentees developed fundamental research skills and received meaningful mentorship from graduate researchers to prepare them for future scholarly pursuits. In turn, graduate student mentors gained experience leading a research team and the conscientious support of undergraduate mentees for their research projects.

Developed in tandem with the student coordinators of the NavCal program, SSRP fills an important gap on-campus for paid, mentored social sciences research opportunities for students who do not have previous research experience. Due to the overwhelmingly positive response to the program, we've expanded it this year.

I was a part of SSRP last year and found the work I was doing very rewarding. My mentor and I stayed in touch and she has supported me through writing an op-ed about her research and immigration issues. She's committed so much time to me and has been an amazing mentor.

— 2020-2021 SSRP undergraduate mentee

STUDENT RESEARCH SPOTLIGHT

Undocumented Research Cohort

Under the guidance of Irene Bloemraad and Cybelle Fox (Sociology), undergraduate students in the IRLE-funded Undocumented Research Cohort examined the Berkeley undocumented student experience and offered recommendations for how the university can better serve undocumented students.

I’m incredibly proud that I work at a world-class research university, and one which puts its public mission front and center. But UCB is huge, and it is easy for students to get lost. This danger is even more acute for our first-generation immigrant students, especially those in precarious legal status. The support of IRLE has been invaluable in carving out a space for undocumented students and their allies to learn, build research skills, and find community.

— Irene Bloemraad, Professor of Sociology

Labor Summer

Now in its third decade, the Labor Center's Labor Summer is a rare paid educational internship that connects students with the labor movement in California. Between 2020 and 2021, over 50 students learned from and worked with labor and community organizations, applying their skills in real-world settings on issues vital to the state’s working people.

Labor Studies at Cal

Professor Ferus-Comelo did an amazing job creating an environment where we can engage in the theoretical and academic writings on the labor movement and learn skills for our future careers... This is honestly the most useful and inspiring class I have taken at Berkeley.

— Fall 2020 Labor Studies student

The Labor Center’s popular Labor Studies courses, taught by Anibel Ferus-Comelo, allow students to hone and apply community-engaged research and organizing skills for social justice while earning academic credit. Last year the courses received two campus honors: “Work, Justice, and the Labor Movement” was awarded a Berkeley Collegium award to narrow the gap between teaching and research, and "Labor Research for Action and Policy" was awarded a Berkeley Changemaker curriculum grant.

Faculty and Research Support

Through funding, grant management, and communications support, IRLE helps to extend the work of faculty engaged in labor- and employment-related scholarship.

We expanded our faculty research grant program this year, providing vital support to 21 research projects totaling over $346,000. These grants advanced timely social sciences research on topics ranging from the impact of the pandemic on ‘barely making it' workers in California, to work environments supporting teachers of color, to the gender pay gap. These awards also funded important GSR opportunities for 15 graduate students. Numerous awardees published in our working paper series.

Our peer-reviewed journal, Industrial Relations, now is its fiftieth year, offers an invaluable international perspective on economic, sociological, psychological, political, historical, and legal developments in labor and employment. It is the only journal in its field with this multidisciplinary focus on the implications of change for business, government and workers.

Faculty Research Awardees

  • Travis Bristol (Education), An Exploration of a Professional Learning Community for Novice Male Teachers of Color
  • Sydnee Caldwell (Business & Economics), Examining the effects of automation on the labor market and on individuals’ political beliefs
  • Ellora Derenoncourt (Economics & Public Policy), Regenerating Opportunity: Black Suburbanization in the South, 1970-2020
  • Supreet Kaur (Economics), High worker turnover and absenteeism: the role of labor supply
  • Erin Kerrison (Social Welfare), Tricycles and Trapdoors: A Mixed-Method Study of Overt and Covert Exclusionary Discipline in Preschools
  • Jonathan Kolstad (Business and Economics), Electronic Medical Records (EMR) and the process of diagnosis and documentation in medicine
  • Claire Montialoux (Public Policy), Racial disparities in Brazil
  • G. Cristina Mora (Sociology and Chicano/Latino Studies ) & Tianna Paschel (Sociology and African American Studies), The Impact of the Covid-19 Pandemic on California’s ‘Barely Making It’
  • Ricardo Perez-Truglia (Business), The Old Boys’ Club: Schmoozing and the Gender Gap
  • Benjamin Schoefer (Economics), Short-Time Work and Unemployment Benefits During COVID-19 / Labor Demand Effects of Financing Constraints and Wage Rigidity
  • Sameer Srivastava (Business), What role does the mobility of organizational leaders play in shaping corporate culture?
  • Guo Xu (Business and Public Policy), The Economic Costs of Employment Segregation: Evidence from the US Federal Government
  • Conrad Miller (Business), Why Are Larger Employers More Racially Diverse?
  • Elizabeth Linos (Public Policy), Reducing Case Worker Burnout to Improve Job Seeker Outcomes: A Field Experiment
  • Avi Feller (Public Policy), Understanding mechanisms driving long-run impacts of 1990s reforms to the safety net
  • Danny Yagan (Economics), The Rise of Pass-Throughs and the Decline in the Labor Share
  • Neil Fligstein (Sociology), Tracking the Impact of Domestic Outsourcing on Employment Outcomes in the United States, 1992 to 2017

Our Centers

IRLE is home to several nationally-recognized centers that conduct research, education, and outreach on pressing labor and employment issues.

The Labor Center develops research and analysis to promote policies that help working families. Its education and leadership trainings are producing a diverse new generation of labor leaders.

California Policy Lab (CPL) partners with state and local policymakers to evaluate and improve public programs through research and technical assistance.

Center for the Study of Child Care Employment (CSCCE) provides research, analysis, and policy solutions on the preparation, working conditions, and compensation of the early care and education workforce.

Center on Wage and Employment Dynamics (CWED) engages in cutting-edge academic and policy research on important economic issues including minimum wage and teacher pay.

California Public Employee Relations (CPER) provides the California public sector with resources to navigate workplace rights.

Research Highlights

Minimum Wage and the Public Cost of Low Wages

IRLE research is informing the public debate on raising the federal minimum wage. Recent studies have shown the high public cost of a low minimum wage and the downstream benefits of higher minimum wages, including reductions to racial wage gaps and deaths of despair.

The Labor Center's Ken Jacobs, along with Anna Godøy, formerly of the Center for Wage and Employment Dynamics, authored a review paper for the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, finding that public policies that raise family incomes, like the minimum wage and the Earned Income Tax Credit, have broad, positive, and long-lasting effects on working families.

In op-eds last year, CPL’s Jesse Rothstein argued that full COVID recovery requires raising the minimum wage; CWED’s Michael Reich outlined how a higher minimum wage would benefit the federal budget; and the Labor Center's Ken Jacobs explained how raising the minimum wage reduces dependency on safety net programs by lifting working families out of poverty.

SELECT PUBLICATIONS

LABOR CENTER RESEARCH HIGHLIGHT

The Public Cost of a Low Federal Minimum Wage

Ken Jacobs, Ian Eve Perry, and Jenifer MacGillvary

Contributing to the national debate on raising the federal minimum wage to $15 through the Raise the Wage Act, this report estimated the public cost of participation in five public safety net programs by families of workers who would receive a direct wage increase under the bill. It found that close to half of these families (47%) are enrolled in at least one program, at an annual cost of $107 billion. The report received significant national attention, including in the Atlantic, Fox Business, NBC News, Money, and the Washington Post.

Deepening Child Care Crisis

The already-strained U.S. early care and education system is collapsing under the pressures of the pandemic, with early childhood educators especially hard hit. The Center for the Study of Child Care Employment (CSCCE) continues to provide state and federal policymakers with groundbreaking analysis of workforce trends, including COVID impacts. Building on decades of research, CSCCE experts developed widely circulated policy recommendations for transformational reform to build an effective public early care and education system that secures gender, racial, and economic justice for early educators.

SELECT PUBLICATIONS

CSCCE RESEARCH SPOTLIGHT

Early Childhood Workforce Index

Caitlin McLean, Lea Austin, Marcy Whitebook, and Krista Olson

This is the moment to be bold about improving the status of the early childhood workforce, and the Index provides the facts and the vision to guide advocates to action."

— Joan Lombardi, former US Deputy Assistant Secretary, Early Childhood Development

The biennial Early Childhood Workforce Index provides a data-rich look at state-based policies and conditions affecting the early care and education workforce. Policy recommendations and findings from the Index detail low wages and high poverty rates among this essential workforce, and informed state and federal policy reform policies, including President Biden's American Families Plan and the U.S. Treasury child care report. In addition, over 400 news outlets referenced the Index in 2021.

The Future of Work

As technology, the pandemic, and the climate crisis alter the landscape of work, IRLE researchers are looking to shape a better future for U.S. workers.

The Labor Center's Green Economy work highlights a path forward for a nationwide economic recovery that advances high-road principles of economic equity, climate resilience, and job quality.

The pandemic has upended the so-called 'gig economy', with hundreds of thousands of app-based rideshare drivers losing work even as reliance on gig workers to home-deliver necessities to consumers has grown dramatically. CWED and Labor Center researchers continue to evaluate the impact of misclassifying workers as independent contractors, finding that misclassification allows app companies to pay workers less than the minimum wage.

A series of reports from the Labor Center’s Technology and Work Program offer a framework for understanding the broad range of data collection strategies and algorithmic systems currently in use or being developed for the workplace, and a snapshot of how unions leverage their collective bargaining agreements to address technological change. Annette Bernhardt, director of the program, co-authored a memo providing recommendations for federal administrative actions to protect worker rights and promote equity in the use of new workplace technologies.

SELECT PUBLICATIONS

LABOR CENTER RESEARCH HIGHLIGHT

Putting California on the High Road: A Jobs and Climate Action Plan for 2030

Carol Zabin

Mandated by the California Legislature, the Jobs and Climate Action Plan for 2030 provides concrete recommendations on how to support California’s working families and high-road employers as the state transitions to a carbon-neutral economy. The plan provides a deep dive into how climate policy can be implemented in a way that bolsters family-supporting jobs and pathways into them for people of color, while protecting the livelihood of workers in industries that may face job loss. The plan also provides a policy roadmap that can help promote the crucial participation of organized labor in the formulation of successful, forward-thinking climate policy.

The recommendations are being implemented in California, as well as applied nationally and in other states considering bold climate action.

Turning the Tables: Participation and Power in Negotiations

Despite the ongoing degradation of workplace and civic democracy, most unions can still choose to transform the negotiations process from a closed one with little input into a key lever for rebuilding robust worker participation.

— Jane McAlevey, Labor Center Senior Policy Fellow

How unions negotiate is a strategic choice. Last year, the Labor Center released a groundbreaking report highlighting how high transparency and high participation are key elements to winning good union contracts. This step-by-step guide offers powerful case studies and practical tools for unions and workers to engage in effective contract negotiations and build workplace democracy.

Photo: Ken Karnas

Social Safety Net

IRLE researchers provide timely analysis of state and federal safety net programs and policy proposals.

California Policy Lab researchers continued to shed light on barriers that prevent eligible, and often vulnerable, Californians from accessing important safety net programs, including CalFresh, unemployment insurance, and federal stimulus payments.

In the lead up to the U.S. Supreme Court's California v. Texas ruling on the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), Labor Center researchers published a series of briefs on how a potential ACA repeal could lead to job losses and a drop in the state GDP as well as a reversal in health coverage gains for low-income Californians.

SELECT PUBLICATIONS

LABOR CENTER RESEARCH HIGHLIGHT

Analyzing California's Progress Toward Universal Access to Health Care

Miranda Dietz, Laurel Lucia, Srikanth Kadiyala, Tynan Challenor, Annie Rak, Dylan H. Roby and Gerald F. Kominsk

The Labor Center’s health research team, partnering with the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research, has continued to analyze the state’s progress toward universal access to health care for California’s residents, providing data on current and future gaps needing to be filled. Last year the team examined the impact of the health coverage provisions in the American Rescue Plan, projecting significant improvements in Covered California affordability and enrollment which will be fleeting in the absence of permanent policy changes.

Separately, the team found that undocumented Californians make up the largest group of the uninsured, with nearly 1.3 million individuals under the age of 65 projected to be uninsured. These findings were cited repeatedly in press coverage of the ground-breaking decision by Governor Newsom and state lawmakers to expand Medi-Cal coverage to all income-eligible adults over age 50, regardless of immigration status.

CALIFORNIA POLICY LAB RESEARCH HIGHLIGHT

The Stimulus Gap: 2.2 Million Californians Could Miss $5.7 Billion in Federal Stimulus Payments

Everything that comes from the California Policy Lab is thoughtful, timely, and grounded in data.

— Julianne McCall, Co-Director of Precision Medicine at CA Governor's Office of Planning & Research

CPL researchers found that more than two million low-income Californians were at risk of not receiving their federal stimulus payments because the payments were distributed through the tax system. The report highlighted how distributing key anti-poverty benefits through the tax code leads to a significant share of the intended audience missing out on the benefits.

COVID Impacts in California and Beyond

IRLE's long track record of empirical inequality and public policy evaluation left our experts well-positioned to provide rapid analysis on how existing inequities shaped workers' experience of the unfolding COVID-19 crisis and what is needed to rebuild a just economy in the wake of the pandemic. IRLE researchers having been providing policymakers and the public with essential insights into the inequitable health and labor market impacts of COVID-19 across industries and demographics, as well as strategies to protect the state's most vulnerable workers.

Analyzing the full range of occupations in California, Labor Center researchers found that workplace social distancing not an option for most California workers, with risk of exposure varying depending on gender, race/ethnicity, and wages.

Researchers at the California Policy Lab continued to provide policymakers with timely snapshots of the pandemic's impact on workers in California and throughout the country using data from the California Employment Development Department and the US Department of Labor.

SELECT PUBLICATIONS

CWED AND LABOR CENTER RESEARCH SPOTLIGHT

Workers and the COVID-19 Recession: Trends in UI Claims & Benefits, Jobs, and Unemployment

Drawing on unemployment insurance numbers and data from the Great Recession, researchers at the Center on Wage and Employment Dynamics (CWED) and the Labor Center analyzed the pandemic’s labor market impacts across demographics and industries and offered early warnings that bold federal action would be required to keep the U.S. out of a depression.

CALIFORNIA POLICY LAB RESEARCH SPOTLIGHT

CalExodus: Are People Leaving California?

Some preliminary data and anecdotes had prompted concerns about a mass exodus from California. In its first research project using its new University of California Consumer Credit Panel (UC-CCP) data, the California Policy Lab garnered widespread media coverage to uncover that the COVID-19 pandemic did not cause a dramatic exodus from California in 2020, though CPL did identify a mini-exodus of San Francisco residents, mostly to other parts of California.

Image by Articles for Small Business (AFSB)

Outreach

The senators who tried to persuade the Senate parliamentarian that [raising the federal minimum wage] would have a positive effect on the federal budget over the next decade relied on [CWED’s Michael] Reich’s fiscal estimates that it would net an additional $65 billion to federal revenues.

- Harold Meyerson, “The Berkeley School” (March 2021)

IRLE research is helping to shape public and policy debates around key issues impacting working families. Our studies are widely cited in major state and national media outlets. Last year, IRLE researchers provided expert testimony and technical assistance to local, state, and national lawmakers, including:

  • U.S. Department of Education
  • U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families
  • U.S. Department of Labor
  • U.S. House Committee on Education and Labor
  • National Council of State Legislatures
  • California Attorney General's Office
  • California Assembly Health Committee
  • Democratic Women's Caucus

Media Highlights

Source: Meltwater Media Monitoring & Social Listening Platform

Financials

Acknowledgements

Thank you to our funders

  • Administration for Children and Families
  • Alfred P. Sloan Foundation
  • Alliance for Early Success
  • Arnold Ventures
  • Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation
  • Blue Shield of California Foundation
  • Bylo Chacon Foundation
  • California Children and Families Commission (First 5 CA)
  • California Department of Education
  • The California Endowment
  • California Health Care Foundation
  • California Wellness Foundation
  • California Workforce Development Board
  • Center for Economic and Policy Research
  • Children’s Council of San Francisco
  • City and County of San Francisco, District Attorney’s Office
  • Clean Slate Initiative
  • Covered California
  • David and Lucile Packard Foundation
  • The Energy Foundation
  • Economic Policy Institute
  • European Research Council
  • Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation
  • Federal Reserve Bank of Boston
  • Ford Foundation
  • Heising-Simons Foundation
  • Institute for Education Studies (IES)
  • Institute for Women’s Policy Research
  • The James Irvine Foundation
  • Los Angeles County Department of Public Health
  • Lyle Spencer Foundation
  • Maryland State Department of Education
  • Massachusetts Institute of Technology, J-PAL North America
  • National Education Association
  • National Endowment for the Arts (NEA)
  • National Science Foundation (NSF)
  • The New School
  • Paris School of Economics
  • Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
  • Rosenberg Foundation
  • Russell Sage Foundation
  • San Francisco Foundation
  • Third Sector New England MissionWorks
  • Tides Foundation
  • Tipping Point Community
  • TRIO Foundation
  • U.S. Department of Labor
  • University of California Office of the President
  • University of Wisconsin-Madison, Institute for Research on Poverty
  • W. Clement & Jessie V. Stone Foundation
  • W.K. Kellogg Foundation
  • Washington Center for Equitable Growth
  • The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation
  • The William T. Grant Foundation

Support our groundbreaking research

The Institute for Research on Labor and Employment promotes better understanding of the conditions, policies, and institutions that affect the well-being of workers and their families and communities. We inform public debate with hard evidence about inequality, the economy, and the nature of work.

Institute for Research on Labor and Employment

2521 Channing Way #5555

Berkeley, California 94720-5555

irle.berkeley.edu | @IRLEUCB